Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil: Smart Lawn Lessons

Trying to choose between Scotts Lawn Soil and regular topsoil? Here’s the deal: Scotts Lawn Soil is made to help grass grow. Topsoil is more for filling low spots. I’ve used both in my yard. Topsoil worked well for leveling. But Scotts made my grass greener and thicker.

After years of lawn care, I’ve learned that the type of soil you use matters. Want to plant new grass or fix bare spots? Keep reading. I’ll share what I’ve learned from real use.

Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil: Easy-to-Read Comparison

I’ve worked on my lawn for years—seeding, patching, and leveling. I’ve used both Scotts Lawn Soil and regular topsoil. If you’re wondering which is better, here’s what I’ve seen.

Nutrient Content: Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil

Scotts Lawn Soil has starter fertilizer and organic stuff. It helps grass grow fast.
Topsoil doesn’t have much unless you mix things in. It’s mostly for filling spots.

Feature	Scotts Lawn Soil	Regular Topsoil
Nutrient Levels	High, with fertilizer	Low, unless mixed with compost
Best Use	Growing grass, seed help	Leveling ground, filler
Organic Matter	Added for roots	Varies, often low

What I saw: Grass grew greener and faster with Scotts. Topsoil needed help—like extra compost or fertilizer.

Rating:

• Scotts Lawn Soil: 9/10
• Topsoil: 6.5/10

👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿

Texture and Feel: Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil

Scotts Lawn Soil feels soft and light. Roots and water move through it easily.
Topsoil can be different. Sometimes it’s fine. Other times, it’s heavy or full of rocks.

Feature	Scotts Lawn Soil	Regular Topsoil
Texture	Light, crumbly	Can be dense or rocky
Drainage	Very good	Depends on mix
Root Growth	Easy for roots	Can be hard for roots

My results: Grass didn’t grow well in topsoil. Once I used Scotts, it took off fast.

Rating:

• Scotts Lawn Soil: 8.5/10
• Topsoil: 6/10

Grass Growth: Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil

Scotts is made to help grass grow. It’s ready to go out of the bag.
Topsoil can work too, but only if you add things.

Feature	Scotts Lawn Soil	Regular Topsoil
Germination Speed	Fast	Slower
Grass Thickness	Full, lush	Thin unless improved
Weeds	Less due to fast growth	More likely

My test: I used the same seed and water. Scotts filled in fast. Topsoil was patchy.

Rating:

• Scotts Lawn Soil: 9.5/10
• Topsoil: 6.5/10

👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿

Cost and Value: Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil

Scotts costs more, but it’s ready to use.
Topsoil is cheaper, but you might need to add stuff.

Feature	Scotts Lawn Soil	Regular Topsoil
Price	Higher	Lower
Extra Needs	None	Compost or fertilizer
Long-Term Results	Strong	Weaker unless improved

My take: I spent more fixing spots where topsoil failed. Scotts saved time in the long run.

Rating:

• Scotts Lawn Soil: 8.5/10
• Topsoil: 7/10

Final Thoughts: Which One to Pick?

If your goal is grass, go with Scotts Lawn Soil. It gives better results.
Topsoil still helps for leveling, but it needs a boost to help grass grow.

Category	Winner
Best for Seeding	Scotts Lawn Soil
Best for Leveling	Regular Topsoil
Easiest to Use	Scotts Lawn Soil
Top Performer	Scotts Lawn Soil

My tip: Use Scotts for seeding. Use topsoil for leveling. That mix worked best for me.

Overall Rating:

• Scotts Lawn Soil: 9/10
• Topsoil: 7/10

👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿

My Simple Soil Strategy for a Thicker, Greener Lawn

A few years ago, I got tired of bare patches that never grew right. After some rough Midwest winters, my lawn looked worn out. I didn’t want to start from scratch, so I tried fixing it with better soil.

At first, I used topsoil. It was cheap and easy to get in bulk. It helped smooth out low spots, but the grass looked dull. It grew slow and felt thin when I walked on it.

Out of frustration, I tried Scotts Lawn Soil. Big difference. In just a week, the grass was thicker, greener, and more even. It looked much better.

What I liked most: Scotts was easy to use. I didn’t need to add compost or fertilizer. It was already mixed in. That saved time. I started using it for reseeding and fixing bare spots. For bigger fills or leveling, I still used topsoil. But I topped it off with a thin layer of Scotts. That combo worked great.

Here’s how I break it down:

• Topsoil is great for leveling or filling deep spots.
• Scotts Lawn Soil is best for reseeding and fixing bare patches.

Using both together works better than either one alone.

Tips for Best Results

• Loosen the top inch of soil before adding new soil. It helps them blend.
• Water lightly after spreading. That helps the soil settle.
• Don’t press it down too hard. Grass roots need air.
• If your soil is heavy clay or sandy, mix in a little compost with topsoil.

Read More: Miracle-Gro vs Vigoro

Final Thoughts: Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil

If you want fast, strong grass growth, go with Scotts Lawn Soil. It costs more, but it saves time and effort. You don’t need to redo bad patches again and again.

Topsoil still helps, especially if you need a lot or are on a tight budget. But if you can, use both. Topsoil first, then a layer of Scotts on top.

That’s my simple soil plan—and it’s worked well for years.

👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿

FAQs: Scotts Lawn Soil vs Topsoil