If you’re trying to choose between the Earthwise and Scotts reel mower, you’re not alone. Both are great picks for clean, chemical-free mowing. But they work best for different yards and people.
I’ve used both in my small backyard in the Midwest. At first, they look the same. But after a few weeks of regular use, the way they feel and cut starts to show a clear difference.
I’ve spent years testing lawn tools. That’s helped me learn what really matters when it comes to manual mowers. Let’s break it down so you can find the one that works best for you.
Table of Contents
Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower: Easy Side-by-Side Guide
I’ve mowed with both Earthwise and Scotts reel mowers in my backyard. At first, they looked the same. But over time, I noticed small changes in how they cut and feel. Those small things made a big difference.
Cutting Width: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Wider cuts mean less mowing time. But bigger mowers can be harder to push.
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Cutting Width | 16 inches | 20 inches |
| Blade Design | 5-blade reel | 5-blade reel |
| Best For | Small, tight yards | Medium-sized lawns |
In my small yard, Earthwise was easier in corners. Scotts covered more ground fast, but felt heavier around trees.
Rating: Earthwise: 8/10 | Scotts: 9/10
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Cutting Height: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Cut height matters for grass type and season. Easy settings help you adjust fast.
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Height Range | 0.5 to 2.5 inches | 1 to 3 inches |
| Adjust Type | Manual knob | Lever |
| Settings | 3 | 9 |
Scotts gave me more choices. That helped as my grass grew. Earthwise was simple but less flexible.
Rating: Earthwise: 7/10 | Scotts: 9/10
Maneuverability: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Handling your mower should feel smooth—not like a workout.
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Weight | 26 lbs | 30 lbs |
| Wheel Size | 10″ | 10″ |
| Turning | Tight | Wider |
Earthwise was lighter and easy to guide. Scotts was solid, but tougher in small spots. I felt it more when mowing one-handed with a coffee in the other.
Rating: Earthwise: 9/10 | Scotts: 7.5/10
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Grass Disposal: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
No bags included—but both offer optional ones.
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Disposal | Rake or bag | Rake or bag |
| Mulch? | No | No |
| Bag? | Sold separate | Sold separate |
I compost, so the bag wasn’t a must. But Scotts’ bag stayed in place better on bumpy spots.
Rating: Earthwise: 7/10 | Scotts: 8/10
Noise Level: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Both are super quiet—great for early mornings.
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Noise | Very quiet | Very quiet |
| Disruption | Low | Low |
| Best Time | Morning | Morning |
I could mow without waking anyone. Both make a light clipping sound, which I actually enjoyed.
Rating: Earthwise: 10/10 | Scotts: 10/10
Ease of Use: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
From setup to storage, ease makes a big difference.
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Setup Time | ~15 mins | ~10 mins |
| Push Feel | Light, smooth | Heavier but firm |
| Storage | Compact | Compact |
Both were easy to build. Earthwise was easier to push, but Scotts felt smoother on flat lawns.
Rating: Earthwise: 9/10 | Scotts: 8/10
Value for Money: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Are you getting your money’s worth?
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Price | $90–$110 | $100–$130 |
| Build | Decent | Very solid |
| Best For | Small yards | Medium lawns |
Earthwise fits small yards and budgets. Scotts gives you more if you have a bigger lawn.
Rating: Earthwise: 8.5/10 | Scotts: 9/10
Final Thoughts: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Here’s how they compare overall:
| Feature | Earthwise | Scotts |
| Best For | Small yards | Medium lawns |
| Feel | Light, nimble | Strong, steady |
| Suited To | Beginners, casual users | Regular mowers, control fans |
If you want something light and easy, Earthwise is a great pick. If you want more control and don’t mind a bit more push, go with Scotts.
Final Score: Earthwise: 8.5/10 | Scotts: 9/10
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
How I Change My Mowing Routine from Spring to Fall
I live in the Midwest, so I’ve learned to change how I mow as the seasons change. Grass doesn’t grow the same in April as it does in August or October.
Spring is about fresh growth. I set the mower blade high to protect the young grass. It helps the lawn grow strong after winter.
In summer, things speed up. After a good rain, my lawn grows thick and fast. I mow every 5 to 7 days to keep it neat. Scotts helps here—the extra height settings let me adjust as needed.
By fall, I mow a bit lower. This gives the yard a clean look and helps it get ready for cold weather. Dry leaves start falling, so I mow more often to stop them from piling up. Both mowers handle light leaves well.
On bumpy spots, Earthwise is easier to push. But when I’m in a rush and need a fast cleanup, Scotts glides better on flat ground.
Tips for Getting the Best Results
After years of using manual mowers in my Midwest backyard, I’ve picked up a few simple tricks for a cleaner cut with less effort:
- Sharpen the blades once a season. Dull blades tear grass instead of cutting it. I sharpen mine in early spring. It makes a big difference.
- Mow when the grass is dry. Wet grass clumps up and can jam the blades. I wait until late morning, once the dew is gone.
- Overlap your passes. A slight overlap helps avoid streaks. I learned this the hard way when I rushed and missed spots.
- Clean the blades after each use. I use a stiff brush and give them a quick wipe. It helps stop rust and keeps the cut smooth.
These steps don’t take long but help a lot. They keep your mower in shape and your lawn looking sharp.
Read More: Black and Decker vs WORX Edger
Final Thoughts on Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Both Earthwise and Scotts reel mowers offer clean, quiet mowing without gas, cords, or noise. But one may fit your yard better than the other.
- Pick Earthwise if you want a light mower that’s easy to handle. It’s great for small yards, tight corners, or mowing around garden beds.
- Choose Scotts if your yard is bigger or more open. It cuts a wider path, has more height settings, and feels solid. It’s ideal for quick cuts after rain or before guests arrive.
Both are strong picks. You don’t need a loud gas mower to keep your lawn neat—just the right tool for your space.
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
FAQs: Earthwise vs Scotts Reel Mower
Which is better: Earthwise or Scotts reel mower?
It depends on your yard. Earthwise is lighter and easy to use in small spaces. Scotts cuts a wider path and works better for medium lawns. Both are quiet and eco-friendly.
Is a Scotts reel mower harder to push than Earthwise?
Yes, a little. Scotts feels heavier, especially in tight spots. Earthwise is lighter and easier to move around trees and flower beds.
Can Earthwise and Scotts reel mowers handle tall grass?
They can struggle with tall or wet grass. Scotts has more height settings, which helps when grass grows fast. To avoid problems, mow often.
Do Earthwise and Scotts reel mowers come with grass catchers?
No, but you can buy bags for both. Scotts’ bag stays on better on rough ground. If you compost, you might not need a bag at all.
Are reel mowers like Earthwise and Scotts good for the U.S. climate?
Yes. They work well in many parts of the U.S., like the Midwest and South. They’re great for small to medium lawns with most grass types.
